Seafood restaurants in Portland, Maine offer different kinds of meals: whole steamed lobster at Luke’s Portland Pier, oysters and cooked entrees at Old Port Sea Grill, or a planned evening at Scales. Choose the format first, then check the menu and seating arrangements. This researched guide compares three options without assigning a universal winner.

What's the best seafood restaurant in Portland, Maine?

There is no defensible single best seafood restaurant for every Portland visit. A whole-lobster meal, a raw bar order and a reserved dinner solve different needs. Start with what your party wants to eat, then decide whether you need daytime service, delivery or a table at a particular hour.

Your priorityStart withCheck before committing
Whole steamed lobsterLuke’s Portland PierCurrent menu and ordering options
Raw bar plus cooked dishesOld Port Sea GrillOyster selection and group preferences
Dinner with advance planningScalesReservation or walk-in arrangements

For more names beyond these three, browse the Portland seafood directory. This comparison narrows the decision by meal format; the directory gives you a wider starting list.

1. Luke’s: Where can you choose whole lobster rather than a roll?

Luke’s Portland Pier lists whole steamed lobster dinners as well as rolls, so you can choose whether to tackle a lobster or order a sandwich. Its menu includes a steamed shore dinner with lobster and clams, alongside clam chowder and fish-and-chips options.

The restaurant is located at 60 Portland Pier on the working waterfront. Posted hours are daily 11am–9pm, with indoor and outdoor seating, a full bar, takeout and delivery. Outdoor seating should be checked for the conditions on your visit.

Use the Luke’s directory profile and its official Portland Pier menu to compare current dishes. The official page also links takeout ordering. Confirm the pickup slot before setting off; a menu listing does not establish immediate availability.

2. Old Port Sea Grill: Where can a raw bar order become a full dinner?

Old Port Sea Grill pairs a raw bar with cooked dinner options, so your table can order oysters alongside an entree. Its menu also lists chicken, steak, a black bean burger and salad, useful to check when not everyone wants shellfish.

At 93 Commercial Street in the Old Port, it is near the waterfront rather than directly on the water. Its posted schedule starts at noon daily. Reservations and delivery links are on the official site; walk-ins depend on availability.

Compare the Old Port Sea Grill profile with its current menu and visit details. Ask about the day’s oyster selection and discuss dietary restrictions directly. A raw bar menu does not establish allergy-safe preparation.

3. Scales: How should you plan a seafood dinner?

Scales is serving dinner nightly for autumn 2026, with advance reservations and a limited allocation of walk-in tables. It is the option here to plan around an evening booking rather than assume daytime service.

The restaurant takes walk-in names at the door beginning half an hour before service. Bar seating is available by reservation for dinner, and complete parties must be present to be seated. Those rules matter if people are arriving separately.

Find it at Maine Wharf, 68 Commercial Street. Use the Scales profile, official booking guidance and seasonal menus before choosing a dish. Menus can change. For a broader evening comparison, see our Fore Street, Scales and Twelve dinner guide.

How this guide was made

Where to Eat Portland made this guide using official restaurant sources checked on November 4, 2026, with AI assistance. It reports menus and operating arrangements, not personal visits, taste tests or rankings. Recheck the linked sources for changes before traveling or booking.

A detail changed?

Help us keep this guide useful. Send a correction.