Pizza in Portland, Maine includes New York-style pies at Pizzaiolo, wood-fired sourdough at Lazzari and Roman pizza at Monte’s Fine Foods. These three places also handle ordering differently. Compare sizes and customization, a reservation request or an early dinner order before choosing where to go. This is a researched menu comparison, not a taste ranking.
Where is the best pizza in Portland, Maine?
There is no single best pizza in Portland, Maine for every order. Your choice depends on the style you want and whether you need a customized pie, a planned restaurant visit or pizza to bring home. Start with those differences instead of treating review scores as interchangeable evidence of quality.
| If you want | Start with | Useful detail |
|---|---|---|
| New York-style size choices | Pizzaiolo | 12-inch and 16-inch pies; build-your-own menu |
| Wood-fired sourdough | Lazzari | Online reservation requests need advance notice |
| Roman pizza | Monte’s Fine Foods | Limited production; call dinner orders earlier |
Compare these locations against the rest of your route before choosing a pickup time.
1. What pizza can you customize at Pizzaiolo?
Pizzaiolo offers build-your-own pizza on New York-style white dough, with 12-inch and 16-inch sizes. Its specialty menu does not allow substitutions, so the build-your-own section is the clear starting point when your group wants to choose toppings.
The menu lists meat and vegetable toppings, plus cheeses including mozzarella, ricotta and vegan cheese. It also lists a 12-inch gluten-free option; that does not establish allergy-safe preparation. Ask the restaurant about ingredients and handling before ordering for a dietary requirement.
Find Pizzaiolo at 360 Cumberland Avenue. Its official website links direct online ordering and delivery services. Compare the food menu with the Pizzaiolo profile before you order online. Pasta, pizzas topped with chicken and salad give the group other dishes to consider alongside a basic cheese pie.
2. How should you plan a visit to Lazzari?
Lazzari serves wood-fired sourdough pizza at 618 Congress Street, with posted opening hours of noon–1am daily. Those are venue hours, so confirm food service before making a late-night trip specifically for pizza.
Its online reservation process is a request for parties of two or more, placed at least 24 hours ahead. The restaurant says it holds a table for ten minutes beyond the expected reservation time. A submitted request should not be treated as a confirmed table.
Use the Lazzari profile, official menu and ordering links and reservation details. The homepage links DoorDash if you prefer delivery. For a broader late meal, see the late-night food guide.
3. Why order Monte’s pizza earlier in the day?
Monte’s recommends calling dinner orders earlier because its Roman pizza production is limited by time and space. The operator describes dough fermented cold for 48 hours and pizza baked twice. That preparation process does not mean an ordinary pizza order requires 48 hours’ notice.
The shop is at 788 Washington Avenue. Posted hours are Monday–Saturday 11am–8pm and Sunday 11am–6pm. Plan around the earlier Sunday closing, and confirm the available pizza and collection time when calling rather than assuming everything remains in stock until close.
Use the Monte’s Fine Foods profile, official pizza and ordering page and contact details. If collecting food is your main requirement, the wider Portland takeout guide compares other pickup options too.
How this guide was made
Where to Eat Portland made this guide using official menus and operating information checked on November 4, 2026, with AI assistance. It describes published choices and ordering rules, not personal visits or restaurant reviews. Recheck menu availability, hours and booking confirmation before traveling.
Help us keep this guide useful. Send a correction.